Pouring Fuel on Fire
Goldman put out a note last week called "Competition for Capital" in which their argument is hyperscalers are spending so much on AI infrastructure that it's eaten up free cash flow and leading them to tap both debt and equity markets. Governments at the same time are borrowing for defence, energy security and infrastructure. We've gone from the post-GFC excess capital to everyone coming to the dinner table at the same time, and the price of money has gone up.
Which got me thinking about a question that sounds stupid when you say it out loud.
Do higher rates cause inflation?
Textbooks obviously say no as when inflation goes up, the central bank lifts rates, money becomes more expensive, demand cools, and inflation comes down. And you keep raising rates until inflation is tempered aka the beatings continue until morale improves.
Earlier this year I wrote about personal investment hurdle rates but it's now worth covering another hurdle rate channel.
Higher interest rates means a higher weighted average cost of capital (WACC). A higher WACC means a higher hurdle, and a higher hurdle means it's harder to justify capital investment meaning fewer projects get built. Fewer projects means less supply, and if demand hasn't gone anywhere, less supply means higher prices. The circle of life for capital markets!
We see this in mining all the time. The <insert commodity> price needed to justify a greenfield project at a 12% discount rate is a very different a price needed at an 8% discount rate. Even with the same orebody, same capex, same strip ratio, if you change the cost of money the incentive price moves too.
So rates up, inflation up?
I haven't answered the question yet, I know
Capex boom pushed up rates, rates kill supply, lack of supply pushes up prices, prices keep rates high, repeat until morale improves. Wrong.
Rates are high because of the boom. If enough projects get cancelled, demand for capital falls and so does the hurdle rate. A rising cost of capital is merely a rationing mechanism. A mechanical method of working out what project gets the money when there isn't enough to go around. Darwinism.
A cancelled project means less demand for inputs. And any supply that doesn't get built only shows up as a problem three to five years out, ie supply is constrained and prices respond. Disinflationary now, inflationary later.
So who gets the short end of the stick?
Definitely not the Hyperscalers!
Today, a hyperscaler could not care less whether its hurdle is 8% or 12%. This is the race for the most valuable technology since electricity and the margins justify the capex spend. Governments are even worse, nobody in Canberra or DC cancels a submarine because the 10YR moved +100bps (or +200bps). Nor should they, investment is required.
The fundamental problem is the two biggest bidders for capital are the least sensitive to the cost of capital. There is no transmission mechanism here at all.
That leaves everyone else to cop it! The apartment developer whose feaso stopped stacking up at 10% borrowing rates and can't access bank capital. The transmission line earning a regulated return. The small industrial business that wanted to borrow for a second site. Any kind of low return, long-duration stuff that makes up a chunk of the actual economy.
How about the family with kids and a mega mortgage in Sydney?
When the RBA or the Fed tightens, they're trying to cool inflation and demand. But if you're battling a dual issue of supply-side energy costs rising (no view on whether the war persists) and demand-side rate insensitivity, then the entire burden to control lands on sectors that were never the problem in the first place!
We are going to end up fighting rising energy prices and an AI & defence boom by shutting down housing construction and consumer expenditure.
So What
Higher rates don't cause inflation but higher rates are going to have no effect if any on inflation today. Sure the Iran War dies down and energy prices normalise, but the structural capex boom and higher rates leads to a higher cost of capital and leads to the wrong people suffering.
Higher rates aren't going to solve supply side issues, probably make it worse. So maybe higher rates then do cause persistent inflation? Dumb question with a dumb answer perhaps.
There is a happy ending here though! Railways, electrification and fibre were all inflationary while being built and deflationary once up and running. If the AI buildout is more or less the same, it represents capital investment for future productivity. Expensive bit before the cheap bit.